Supreme Court Decisions
Philippine Supreme Court Decisions: 2000
- G.R. No. 128230 ROCKWELL PERFECTO GOHU, PETITIONER, VS. SPOUSES ALBERTO GOHU AND ADELAIDA GOHU, RESPONDENTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 120077 THE MANILA HOTEL CORP. AND MANILA HOTEL INTL. LTD. PETITIONERS, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, ARBITER CEFERINA J. DIOSANA AND MARCELO G. SANTOS, RESPONDENTS. D E C I S I O N
- A.M. No. 00-1-48- [ A.M. No. 00-1-48-RTC. October 12, 2000 ]
- G.R. No. 122451 CAGAYAN ROBINA SUGAR MILLING CO., PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, CENTRAL BOARD OF ASSESSMENT APPEALS, BOARD OF ASSESSMENT APPEALS, AND THE PROVINCIAL ASSESSOR OF CAGAYAN, RESPONDENTS. DECISION
- A.M. No. 00-1395 FRANCIA MERILO-BEDURAL, COMPLAINANT, VS. OSCAR EDROSO,[1] RESPONDENT. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 127316 LIGHT RAIL TRANSIT AUTHORITY, PETITIONER, VS. CENTRAL BOARD OF ASSESSMENT APPEALS, BOARD OF ASSESSMENT APPEALS OF MANILA AND THE CITY ASSESSOR OF MANILA, RESPONDENTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 106634 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. NINOY MALBOG @ SATURNINO MALBOG, AMADEO VIERNES* AND SALVADOR BAMBILLA, ACCUSED-APPELLANTS. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 97913 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. NORBERTO CARROZO* @ "BORBING", CLAVER CARROZO @ "CLAVER", DOMINADOR** ANTOJADO @ "BADIC", DOMINGO POLINGA*** @ "DOMING", WILFREDO MANTO @ "DOYDOY", PRECILO MANTO @ "ONTOY", CARLOS CARROZO @ "DONGDONG" AND RODULFO REDUBLA****@ "RUDY", ACCUSED. CARLOS CARROZO @ "DONGDONG", PRECILO MANTO @ ;"ONTOY", WILFREDO MANTO @ "DOYDOY", AND DOMINADOR ANTOJADO @ "BADIC", ACCUSED-APPELLANTS. DECISION
- G.R. Nos. 135695-96 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. TOMAS TUNDAG, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. DECISION
- G.R. No. 139524 PHILIP C. SANTOS AND HEIRS OF ELISEO M. SANTOS, PETITIONERS, VS. LADISLAO M. SANTOS REPRESENTED HEREIN BY HIS ATTORNEY-IN-FACT NOE M. SANTOS, RESPONDENTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 137378 PHILIPPINE ALUMINUM WHEELS, INC., PETITIONER, VS. FASGI ENTERPRISES, INC., RESPONDENT. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 119832 RAYMUNDO TAN, JR., AND EDUARDO TAN, PETITIONERS, VS. THE COURT OF APPEALS AND PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, RESPONDENTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 122047 SPOUSES SERAFIN SI AND ANITA BONODE SI, PETITIONERS, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, SPOUSES JOSE ARMADA AND REMEDIOS ALMANZOR (DECEASED, AND SUBSTITUTED BY HEIRS: CYNTHIA ARMADA, DANILO ARMADA AND VICENTE ARMADA) RESPONDENTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 138596 SR. FIDELIS ARAMBULO, PETITIONER, VS. HON. HILARION LAQUI, SR. HELEN OJARIO AND SR. BERNADINE JUAREZ, RESPONDENTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 127130 THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. ERNESTO EBIAS Y MAGANA, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 139020 PAQUITO BUAYA, PETITIONER, VS. STRONGHOLD INSURANCE CO., INC., RESPONDENT. DECISION
- G.R. No. 130177 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. JOAQUIN BARRAMEDA AND ADOLFO BELGA, ACCUSED-APPELLANTS. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 109143 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. PEDRO G. TALIMAN, BASILIO M. BAYBAYAN, AMADO B. BELANO, DANILO OBENIA AND RUFINO VALERA, JR., ACCUSED, PEDRO G. TALIMAN, BASILIO M. BAYBAYAN AND AMADO B. BELANO, ACCUSED-APPELLANTS. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 120897 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. SEVERO DAYUHA Y DASO, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 109853 PROVINCE OF ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE, REPRESENTED BY GOV. ISAGANI S. AMATONG, PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE, INC., RESPONDENTS. D E C I S I O N
- A.M. No. 00-2-27- [ A.M. No. 00-2-27-MTCC. October 10, 2000 ]
- G.R. No. 138570 BAYAN (BAGONG ALYANSANG MAKABAYAN), A JUNK VFA MOVEMENT, BISHOP TOMAS MILLAMENA (IGLESIA FILIPINA INDEPENDIENTE), BISHOP ELMER BOLOCAN (UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST OF THE PHIL.), DR. REYNALDO LEGASCA, MD, KILUSANG MAMBUBUKID NG PILIPINAS, KILUSANG MAYO UNO, GABRIELA, PROLABOR, AND THE PUBLIC INTEREST LAW CENTER, PETITIONERS, VS. EXECUTIVE SECRETARY RONALDO ZAMORA, FOREIGN AFFAIRS SECRETARY DOMINGO SIAZON, DEFENSE SECRETARY ORLANDO MERCADO, BRIG. GEN. ALEXANDER AGUIRRE, SENATE PRESIDENT MARCELO FERNAN, SENATOR FRANKLIN DRILON, SENATOR BLAS OPLE, SENATOR RODOLFO BIAZON, AND SENATOR FRANCISCO TATAD, RESPONDENTS. [G.R. No. 138572] PHILIPPINE CONSTITUTION ASSOCIATION, INC.(PHILCONSA), EXEQUIEL B. GARCIA, AMADOGAT INCIONG, CAMILO L. SABIO, AND RAMON A. GONZALES, PETITIONERS, VS. HON. RONALDO B. ZAMORA, AS EXECUTIVE SECRETARY, HON. ORLANDO MERCADO, AS SECRETARY OF NATIONAL DEFENSE, AND HON. DOMINGO L. SIAZON, JR., AS SECRETARY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS, RESPONDENTS. [G.R. No. 138587] TEOFISTO T. GUINGONA, JR., RAUL S. ROCO, AND SERGIO R. OSMEÑA III, PETITIONERS, VS. JOSEPH E. ESTRADA, RONALDO B. ZAMORA, DOMINGO L. SIAZON, JR., ORLANDO B. MERCADO, MARCELO B. FERNAN, FRANKLIN M. DRILON, BLAS F. OPLE AND RODOLFO G. BIAZON, RESPONDENTS. [G.R. No. 138680] INTEGRATED BAR OF THE PHILIPPINES, REPRESENTED BY ITS NATIONAL PRESIDENT, JOSE AGUILA GRAPILON, PETITIONERS, VS. JOSEPH EJERCITO ESTRADA, IN HIS CAPACITY AS PRESIDENT, REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, AND HON. DOMINGO SIAZON, IN HIS CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS, RESPONDENTS. [G.R. No. 138698] JOVITO R. SALONGA, WIGBERTO TAÑADA, ZENAIDA QUEZON-AVENCEÑA, ROLANDO SIMBULAN, PABLITO V. SANIDAD, MA. SOCORRO I. DIOKNO, AGAPITO A. AQUINO, JOKER P. ARROYO, FRANCISCO C. RIVERA JR., RENE A.V. SAGUISAG, KILOSBAYAN, MOVEMENT OF ATTORNEYS FOR BROTHERHOOD, INTEGRITY AND NATIONALISM, INC. (MABINI), PETITIONERS, VS. THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY, THE SECRETARY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS, THE SECRETARY OF NATIONAL DEFENSE, SENATE PRESIDENT MARCELO B. FERNAN, SENATOR BLAS F. OPLE, SENATOR RODOLFO G. BIAZON, AND ALL OTHER PERSONS ACTING THEIR CONTROL, SUPERVISION, DIRECTION, AND INSTRUCTION IN RELATION TO THE VISITING FORCES AGREEMENT (VFA), RESPONDENTS. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 133511 HON. WILLIAM G. PADOLINA, IN HIS CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF THE DEPARTMENT OF SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY (DOST) AND DR. LEONCIO A. AMADORE, IN HIS CAPACITY AS DIRECTOR, PHILIPPINE ATMOSPHERIC, GEOGRAPHICAL AND ASTRONOMICAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION (PAGASA), PETITIONERS, VS. OFELIA D. FERNANDEZ, RESPONDENT. R E S O L U T I O N
- G.R. No. 128002 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. BIENVENIDO BONITO Y BEDAÑA @ "BINDOY", EDILBERTO (ROBERTO) CANDELARIA @ "BENTONG" AND DOMINGO BUIZA, ACCUSED-APPELLANTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 132168 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. JOSELITO LOPEZ Y FRANCISCO, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 138979 ERNESTO BUNYE, PETITIONER, VS. LOURDES AQUINO, CITA AQUINO AND ROBERTO AQUINO, RESPONDENTS. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 108615 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. NILO VEDRA,[1] ACCUSED-APPELLANT. DECISION
- G.R. Nos. 128110-11 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. RENE UBALDO Y MANIPON, EMAN POSOS Y ARMENTO, LITO MONTEJO Y MAHINAY, ACCUSED-APPELLANTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 128121 PHILIPPINE CREOSOTING CORPORATION, MONINA REALTY CORPORATION AND SPOUSES PETER C. NEPOMUCENO AND MONINA B. NEPOMUCENO, PETITIONERS, VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND PACWOOD, INC., RESPONDENTS. [G.R. No. 128993] PACWOOD, INC., PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, PHILIPPINE CREOSOTING CORPORATION, MONINA REALTY CORPORATION AND SPOUSES PETER C. NEPOMUCENO AND MONINA B. NEPOMUCENO, RESPONDENTS. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 125468 PRODUCERS BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES, PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, NEW COTTON (PHIL.) CORP., LAN SHING CHIN, SHIN MAY WAN AND NELSON KHO, RESPONDENTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 140904 RENE S. ONG, MAGDALENO B. ALBARRACIN, JR., PETRONIO C. AALIWIN AND J. O. NERIT, PETITIONERS, VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES AND COURT OF APPEALS, RESPONDENTS. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. Nos. 112792-93 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. RAUL TAGUBA Y REYNOSO AND JAIME TOLIBAS Y CAMPOSANO, ACCUSED, RAUL TAGUBA Y REYNOSO, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. DECISION
- G.R. Nos. 133448-53 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. ROSELINDO CUTAMORA AND ALLAN CUTAMORA, ACCUSED-APPELLANTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 136781 VETERANS FEDERATION PARTY, ALYANSANG BAYANIHAN NG MGA MAGSASAKA, MANGGAGAWANG BUKID AT MANGINGISDA, ADHIKAIN AT KILUSAN NG ORDINARYONG TAO PARA SA LUPA, PABAHAY AT KAUNLARAN, AND LUZON FARMERS PARTY, PETITIONERS, VS. COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS, PAG-ASA, SENIOR CITIZENS, AKAP AKSYON, PINATUBO, NUPA, PRP, AMIN, PAG-ASA, MAHARLIKA, OCW-UNIFIL, PCCI, AMMA-KATIPUNAN, KAMPIL, BANTAY-BAYAN, AFW, ANG LAKAS OCW, WOMEN-POWER, INC., FEJODAP, CUP, VETERANS CARE, 4L, AWATU, PMP, ATUCP, NCWP, ALU, BIGAS, COPRA, GREEN, ANAKBAYAN, ARBA, MINFA, AYOS, ALL COOP, PDP-LABAN, KATIPUNAN, ONEWAY PRINT, AABANTE KA PILIPINAS -- ALL BEING PARTY-LIST PARTIES/ORGANIZATIONS -- AND HON. MANUEL B. VILLAR, JR. IN HIS CAPACITY AS SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, RESPONDENTS. [G.R. No. 136786] AKBAYAN! (CITIZENS' ACTION PARTY), ADHIKAIN AT KILUSAN NG ORDINARYONG TAO PARA SA LUPA, PABAHAY AT KAUNLARAN (AKO), AND ASSOCIATION OF PHILIPPINE ELECTRIC COOPERATIVES (APEC), PETITIONERS, VS. COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS (COMELEC), HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES REPRESENTED BY SPEAKER MANUEL B. VILLAR, PAG-ASA, SENIOR CITIZENS, AKAP, AKSYON, PINATUBO, NUPA, PRP, AMIN, MAHARLIKA, OCW, UNIFIL, PCCI, AMMA-KATIPUNAN, KAMPIL, BANTAY-BAYAN, AFW, ANG LAKAS OCW, WOMENPOWER INC., FEJODAP, CUP, VETERANS CARE, FOUR "L", AWATU, PMP, ATUCP, NCWP, ALU, BIGAS, COPRA, GREEN, ANAK-BAYAN, ARBA, MINFA, AYOS, ALL COOP, PDP-LABAN, KATIPUNAN, ONEWAY PRINT, AABANTE KA PILIPINAS, RESPONDENTS. [G.R. No. 136795] ALAGAD (PARTIDO NG MARALITANG-LUNGSOD), NATIONAL CONFEDERATION OF SMALL COCONUT FARMERS' ORGANIZATIONS (NCSFCO), AND LUZON FARMERS' PARTY (BUTIL), PETITIONERS, VS. COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS, SENIOR CITIZENS, AKAP, AKSYON, PINATUBO, NUPA, PRP, AMIN, PAG-ASA, MAHARLIKA, OCW, UNIFIL, PCCI, AMMA-KATIPUNAN, KAMPIL, BANTAY-BAYAN, AFW, ANG LAKAS OCW, WOMENPOWER INC., FEJODAP, CUP, VETERANS CARE, 4L, AWATU, PMP, ATUCP, NCWP, ALU, BIGAS, COPRA, GREEN, ANAK-BAYAN, ARBA, MINFA, AYOS, ALL COOP, PDP-LABAN, KATIPUNAN, ONEWAY PRINT, AND AABANTE KA PILIPINAS, RESPONDENTS. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 119602 WILDVALLEY SHIPPING CO., LTD. PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND PHILIPPINE PRESIDENT LINES INC., RESPONDENTS. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. Nos. 134143-47 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, APPELLEE, VS. ALFREDO CATUBIG JR., NIÑO P. REPIA, JOHN DOE, PETER DOE AND WILLIAM DOE, ACCUSED, ALFREDO CATUBIG JR., APPELLANT. DECISION
- G.R. No. 130613 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. ARTEMIO AQUINO A.K.A. ARTEM AND ERNESTO AQUINO A.K.A. ERNING, ACCUSED. ARTEMIO AQUINO A.K.A. ARTEM, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 131942 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. CARLITO BAWANG, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. DECISION
- G.R. Nos. 115251-52 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. JOHN DEE Y OFIDO AND ALEX SALANGA Y VALDEZ, ACCUSED-APPELLANTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 133904 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. RODOLFO DELA CUESTA, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. DECISION
- G.R. No. 129532 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. VICENTE HILOT (DECEASED) AND PATROCINIO BIHAG, JR., ACCUSED, PATROCINIO BIHAG, JR., ACCUSED-APPELLANT. DECISION
- G.R. No. 139592 REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES REP. BY THE DEPARTMENT OF AGRARIAN REFORM, PETITIONER, VS. HON. COURT OF APPEALS AND GREEN CITY ESTATE & DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, RESPONDENTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 111904 SPS. AGRIPINO GESTOPA AND ISABEL SILARIO GESTOPA, PETITIONERS, VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND MERCEDES DANLAG Y PILAPIL, RESPONDENTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 137798 LUCIA R. SINGSON, PETITIONER, VS. CALTEX (PHILIPPINES), INC. RESPONDENT. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 127405 MARJORIE TOCAO AND WILLIAM T. BELO, PETITIONERS, VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND NENITA A. ANAY, RESPONDENTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 132633 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. ARMANDO GEMOYA, AND RONILO TIONKO, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. Nos. 134480-82 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. GREGORIO MAGTRAYO, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. D E C I S I O N
- G.R. No. 129371 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. ROMEO SANTIAGO, SOLIS DE LEON AND JAIME ILLESCAS, ACCUSED, JAIME ILLESCAS, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. DECISION
- G.R. No. 128559 THE SECRETARY OF EDUCATION, CULTURE AND SPORTS, AND THE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION, PETITIONERS, VS. COURT OF APPEALS; ABENIS, ERLINDA; ACHACON, JULIAN; ACOL, SOCORRO; AFAN, MA. ANA; AGULTO, ANGELITA; ALE, JANET; ALETA, NORMA; ALFISAR, VILMA; ALPINO, ANITA; AMAROSO, MILANDRO; AMBROSIO, CAINA; ANAZARIO, RICARDO; ANDRES, MILAGROS; ATENDIDO, ROSITA; ANTONIO, MARCELLANA; APOSTOL, HERMINIA; ARCEO, RAON; ARCILLA, ROSALINDA; ARGAMOZA, ROGELIA; ARRIAGA, EULALIA; ASUNCION, CORAZON; BALATBAT, ANITA; BANAWA, MARIA; BANGALISAN, MA. PAZ; BANIGUED, ZENAIDA; BARCELON, TEOFILO; BARTOLOME, DIVINA; BARTOLOME, PURITA; BATERNA, LUZ; BUSTILLOS, JOSE; CARANDANG, SOFIA; CARPIO, REMEDIOS; CAYTON, LUCILA; CERDENA, ZENAIDA; CLEMENTE, PROSPERINA; CONSTANTINO, VIVIEN; CRUZ, LUISA DELA; DABANDAN, ILUMINADA; DAVID, ENCARNACION; DAVID, VERONICA; DAYNITA, MA. BEATA; DAYRIT, VILLAFLOR; DECELLA, ROLANDO; DEDACE, ANGELITO; DE GUZMAN, VIRGINIA; DELANTOR, TERESITA; DE LUNA, FELICITAS; DE PEDRO, MARCELINA; DELA PAZ, ROSALINDA; DIAZ, IRENE; DIAZ, ROSARIO; DIMACALI, ROSARIA; DIONISIO, WILLIAM; DIZON, NENITA; DOLORES, CYNTHIA; DOMANTAY, FLORENCIA; DOMINGO, DIVINA; ECHALAS, TERESITA; ENRIQUEZ, LILIAN; ENRIQUEZ, LORNA; ERNI, LYDIA; ESPINA, ERLINDA; ESPINOZA, GLORIA; ESPIRITU, ALFREDO; ESPIRITU, LUZ; ESPIRITU, PETRONILA; ESQUERRA, LUZVIMINDA; ESTRADA, ELSA; ESTRADA, MARILYN; ESTRADA, VITA; EUGENIO, ELEANOR; EUGENIO, TERESA; EUSTAQUIO, ISABELITA; FARINAS, LITA; FELIX, EMELITA; FERIA, EVA; FIEDACAN, EMILIE; FUERTES, ARSENIA; HAGOS, JOSE; HALOG, ESTRELLA; HAMID, EDELWISSA; IBLOQUIN, ROMEO; IDOS, REBECCA; JOLOC, CHARITA; KIMPO, AMELIA; LABIRAN, MARINA; LAPUT, ESTELA; LAYOSO, BEN; LEON, JULITA DE; LIWAG, MILAGROS; MADEJA, WILFREDO; MALILAY, SEVERA; MANUBA, ISABELA; MARTINEZ, LIBERTAD; MEJIA, TERESITA; NATIVIDAD, EVELYN; ORDINARIO, DOLORES; ORTALIZA, JUAN; PACLEB, VICTORIA; PAGDANGANAN, GREGORIA; PALISOC, JOSEFINA; PAREJA, ADELINA; PASTRANA, MARCOSA; PELAYO, LUCITA; PROTON, JULITA; RAMOS, BELEN; RAMONES, CARMELITA; RED, ERLINDA; REJAN0, VIOLETA; REVILLA, LOURDES; RIVER, ALEX; RODRIN, VIOLETA; RONGCALES, SOLEDAD; ROQUE, MILAGROS; ROXAS, LOURDES; ROYOLA, ELINITA; RUTGER, ANGEL; SACDAL, NATIVDAD; SADANG, MARCELA; SADIE, REBECCA; SANCHEZ, FE; SANCHEZ, OFELIA; SANCHEZ, REBECCA; SANDOGON, YOLANDA; SANTOS, ASUCENA; SANTOS, CYNTHIA; SANTOS, JESSIEBEL; SANTOS, MA. VICTORIA; SANTOS, ROSA; SANTOS, TRINIDAD; SAN GABRIEL, ASUNCION; SIENNA, ARTHUR; SISALIN, MA. LINDA; SISON, NORMA; SORIANO, EVA; SORIANO, MARINA; SOSA, ARISTON; STO. DOMINGO, MARILYN; SUAN, ELVIRA; SUNSA, EDITH; SY, BERNADETTE; TABIANDO, HELEN; TALLION, LETICIA; TAN, EVANGELINE; TAN, NENITA; TAVIOS, BLANCHE; TECSON, ESPERANZA; TEODORO, JOSEFINA; TERRADO, TORIBIO; TOGUENO, NORMA; TOLENTINO, LETICIA; TRINIDAD, HEREDITA; UMALI, SERGIA; VALENCIA, PRISCA; VARGAS, LOURDES; VELASCO, LOLITA; VELASCO, MILAGROS; VELASQUEZ, MARIA; VIADOR, PENNSYLVANIA; VICENTE, SHIRLEY; VILLANUEVA, DANIEL; VILLANUEVA, NELIA; VILLAPANDO, AMPARO; VILLARIN, ARLENE; VILLARUEL, ANECITA; VILLALBA, FRANCIA; VISTAN, AMELIA; VIVAS, EDITH; YANZA, CORAZON; YAO, ANA MARIA; YERO, ELENA; YUMUL ERLINDA; AND ZAGALA, DALISAY, RESPONDENTS. [G.R. No. 130911] ABENIS, ERLINDA; ACHACON, JULIAN; ACOL, SOCORRO; AFAN, MA. ANA; AGULTO, ANGELITA; ALE, JANET; ALETA, NORMA; ALFISAR, VILMA; ALPINO, ANITA; AMAROSO, MILANDRO; AMBROSIO, CAINA; ANAZARIO, RICARDO; ANDRES, MILAGROS; ATENDIDO, ROSITA; ANTONIO, MARCELLANA; APOSTOL, HERMINIA; ARCEO, RAON; ARCILLA, ROSALINDA; ARGAMOZA, ROGELIA; ARRIAGA, EULALIA; ASUNCION, CORAZON; BALATBAT, ANITA; BANAWA, MARIA; BANGALISAN, MA. PAZ; BANIGUED, ZENAIDA; BARCELON, TEOFILO; BARTOLOME, DIVINA; BARTOLOME, PURITA; BATERNA, LUZ; BUSTILLOS, JOSE; CARANDANG, SOFIA; CARPIO, REMEDIOS; CAYTON, LUCILA; CERDENA, ZENAIDA; CLEMENTE, PROSPERINA; CONSTANTINO, VIVIEN; CRUZ, LUISA DELA; DABANDAN, ILUMINADA; DAVID, ENCARNACION; DAVID, VERONICA; DAYNITA, MA. BEATA; DAYRIT, VILLAFLOR; DECELLA, ROLANDO; DEDACE, ANGELITO; DE GUZMAN, VIRGINIA; DELANTOR, TERESITA; DE LUNA, FELICITAS; DE PEDRO, MARCELINA; DELA PAZ, ROSALINDA; DIAZ, IRENE; DIAZ, ROSARIO; DIMACALI, ROSARIA; DIONISIO, WILLIAM; DIZON, NENITA; DOLORES, CYNTHIA; DOMANTAY, FLORENCIA; DOMINGO, DIVINA; ECHALAS, TERESITA; ENRIQUEZ, LILIAN; ENRIQUEZ, LORNA; ERNI, LYDIA; ESPINA, ERLINDA; ESPINOZA, GLORIA; ESPIRITU, ALFREDO; ESPIRITU, LUZ; ESPIRITU, PETRONILA; ESQUERRA, LUZVIMINDA; ESTRADA, ELSA; ESTRADA, MARILYN; ESTRADA, VITA; EUGENIO, ELEANOR; EUGENIO, TERESA; EUSTAQUIO, ISABELITA; FARINAS, LITA; FELIX, EMELITA; FERIA, EVA; FIEDACAN, EMILIE; FUERTES, ARSENIA; HAGOS, JOSE; HALOG, ESTRELLA; HAMID, EDELWISSA; IBLOQUIN, ROMEO; IDOS, REBECCA; JOLOC, CHARITA; KIMPO, AMELIA; LABIRAN, MARINA; LAPUT, ESTELA; LAYOSO, BEN; LEON, JULITA DE; LIWAG, MILAGROS; MADEJA, WILFREDO; MALILAY, SEVERA; MANUBA, ISABELA, MARTINEZ, LIBERTAD; MEJIA, TERESITA; NATIVIDAD, EVELYN; ORDINARIO, DOLORES; ORTALIZA, JUAN; PACLEB, VICTORIA; PAGDANGANAN, GREGORIO; PALISOC, JOSEFINA; PAREJA, ADELINA; PASTRANA, MARCOSA; PELAYO, LUCITA; PROTON, JULITA; RAMOS, BELEN; RAMONES, CARMELITA; RED, ERLINDA; REJAN0, VIOLETA; REVILLA, LOURDES; RIVER, ALEX; RODRIN, VIOLETA; RONGCALES, SOLEDAD; ROQUE, MILAGROS; ROXAS, LOURDES; ROYOLA, ELINITA; RUTGER, ANGEL; SACDAL, NATIVDAD; SADANG, MARCELA; SADIE, REBECCA; SANCHEZ, FE; SANCHEZ, OFELIA; SANCHEZ, REBECCA; SANDOGON, YOLANDA; SANTOS, ASUCENA; SANTOS, CYNTHIA; SANTOS, JESSIEBEL; SANTOS, MA. VICTORIA; SANTOS, ROSA; SANTOS, TRINIDAD; SAN GABRIEL, ASUNCION; SIENNA, ARTHUR; SISALIN, MA. LINDA; SISON, NORMA; SORIANO, EVA; SORIANO, MARINA; SOSA, ARISTON; STO. DOMINGO, MARILYN; SUAN, ELVIRA; SUNSA, EDITH; SY, BERNADETTE; TABIANDO, HELEN; TALLION, LETICIA; TAN, EVANGELINE; TAN, NENITA; TAVIOS, BLANCHE; TECSON, ESPERANZA; TEODORO, JOSEFINA; TERRADO, TORIBIO; TOGUENO, NORMA; TOLENTINO, LETICIA; TRINIDAD, HEREDITA; UMALI, SERGIA; VALENCIA, PRISCA; VARGAS, LOURDES; VELASCO, LOLITA; VELASCO, MILAGROS; VELASQUEZ, MARIA; VIADOR, PENNSYLVANIA; VICENTE, SHIRLEY; VILLANUEVA, DANIEL; VILLANUEVA, NELIA; VILLAPANDO, AMPARO; VILLARIN, ARLENE; VILLARUEL, ANECITA; VILLALBA, FRANCIA; VISTAN, AMELIA; VIVAS, EDITH; YANZA, CORAZON; YAO, ANA MARIA; YERO, ELENA; YUMUL ERLINDA; AND ZAGALA, DALISAY, PETITIONERS, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, THE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION AND THE SECRETARY OF EDUCATION, CULTURE AND SPORTS, RESPONDENTS. DECISION
- G.R. No. 126881 HEIRS OF TAN ENG KEE, PETITIONERS, VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND BENGUET LUMBER COMPANY, REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT TAN ENG LAY, RESPONDENTS. D E C I S I O N